June 2006
Woody Wax made cleanup of dirt
and fish-blood stains easy - and it improved on-deck
traction. Aurora's Sure Step was the slickest.
Scrubbing the decks is one of the
most monotonous maintenance jobs on a boat. And it's
a tough task because most decks are covered with
nonskid material, with all of its nooks and crannies
that make removal of dirt, grime, mud, or fish blood
all that much harder. What if you could coat your
boat's nonskid decks with a protectant that would
make cleanup a whole lot easier? The decks wouldn't
even have to be scrubbed, just rinsed clean? Well,
we found three products that claim to do just this.
These nonskid "waxes" are supposed to do their job
without making the nonskid slippery. One product,
Aurora's Sure Step, actually claims to increase the
traction of the nonskid. We decided to see about
that.
What we tested
We tested a trio of products: Sure
Step from Aurora Marine, Woody Wax from Tower Plus
2000, and Star brite Non-skid Deck Cleaner. As the
name says, the Star brite is a cleaner, but it
contains a Teflon-like substance (the Company calls
it PTEF) that leaves a protective coating. The other
two products are strictly protectants. They do,
however, require that the decks be clean before
application. In fact, Aurora recommends applying two
of its other products to clean the surface. Richard
Kittar, the owner of Aurora, said there's a risk
that residue from other cleaners can get trapped
under the Aurora Sure Step and lead to
discoloration. This won't happen if Aurora Boat
Clean and Aurora Boat Scrub are used on the nonskid
first, he said. The three products are sold as a
package for $31.37.
No special cleaners are required
with Woody Wax. It can be applied to clean decks, wet
or dry. You let it dry for 20 to 30 minutes, rinse
with water, and buff with a clean cloth. Application
of Aurora Sure Step is similar: Apply with a brush,
let dry (no time is specified), and buff with a
brush. Apply the Star brite with a deck brush, too,
then allow it to sit for two to three minutes. Scrub
and rinse.
How we tested
We thoroughly cleaned three small
sections of the nonskid-covered (diamond pattern)
cockpit sole of our Neptune 212 test boat. We
applied each product, following the directions
carefully. The test was a two-day affair because
Aurora requires a second application of its Sure
Step after 24 hours. The remainder of the sole was
cleaned but left untreated.
We wanted to evaluate how well each
product resisted dirt and stains. We also wanted to
see if these substances added or detracted from the
"grippiness" of the nonskid. So we took a bucket of
mud and brushed it on a portion of each treated
section. And for a stain, testers/anglers secured
some fish blood from a very unwilling 3-pound
Spanish mackerel (yes, sometimes the job has its
benefits) and splattered it on our test sections. We
let the mud and blood cook in the 85-degree sun and
then rinsed the deck with a garden hose.
The Neptune was on its trailer,
which worked out well for our traction test. We used
a forklift to raise the trailer tongue and put the
boat at a 15-degree angle. We stood on each section
with bare feet and two types of footwear: boat shoes
and boat sneakers. We tested with the decks dry and
wet.
Results
In the traction test, Woody Wax came
out on top, followed by Star brite and Aurora.
Testers noticed little difference between the
sections when they wore boat shoes or boat sneakers.
Differences emerged when testers shed their footwear
and the deck was wet, however. The Woody Wax clearly
provided the best traction. The Aurora section was
the slickest, about equal to the adjacent untreated
deck. The Star brite's section as a bit grippier
than the untreated deck.
In our ease-of-cleaning test, the
Woody Wax prevailed again. We were able to completely
remove the blood and mud from its section after a
rinsing and a light scrubbing with a soft brush (no
soap). The mud was similarly brushed off the Star brite and the Aurora sections, but blood stains
remained. The stain on the Star brite panel was more
evident than the one on the Aurora section.
Conclusions
The Woody Wax flat-out works. It is
relatively easy to apply. It left a nice shine on
our deck. And most importantly, it resisted mud and
blood stains. Woody Wax is expensive ($28.60 through
the manufacturer). But if you're an active boater
constantly cleaning your nonskid, then it's worth
the money, in our opinion. To get the nonskid clean,
we recommend 3M or
Meguiar's nonskid cleaners (see
January 2005 issue).
We plan to check the treated deck
sections after six months and publish an update.
© Copyright Belvoir
Publications, Inc. All rights reserved. |